Let's talk about a movie that, despite its star-studded cast, managed to slip through the cracks for many viewers. Morgan Freeman, Michael Caine, and Alan Arkin in a heist comedy? It sounds like a recipe for success, but the 2017 Netflix film "Going in Style" didn't quite live up to expectations.
The original "Going in Style" from 1979, directed by Martin Brest, is a gem that often gets overlooked. It's a character-driven story about three senior citizens who decide to rob a bank, offering a unique blend of humor and bittersweet regret. This film is a prime example of how a simple premise can be elevated by sensitive storytelling.
Now, let's delve into the remake directed by Zach Braff. Working with a script by Theodore Melfi, Braff takes us to a sanitized version of Brooklyn, a far cry from the gritty realism of the original. The charm of the 1979 film, where George Burns' character spontaneously decides to rob a bank, is replaced by a more formulaic underdog narrative. Our heroes, played by Freeman, Caine, and Arkin, are reduced to bumbling amateurs, and the story adds unnecessary dramatic elements like Freeman's character's kidney failure and Caine's character's inspiration to rob a bank after witnessing one.
What makes this particularly fascinating is the contrast between the two films. Brest's approach was grounded and focused on the characters' journey, while Braff's remake feels like a generic underdog tale with a forced emotional arc. The remake's lack of comedic inventiveness and its departure from the original's charm are what, in my opinion, led to its underwhelming reception.
One thing that immediately stands out is the difference in tone. The original had a casual, fun vibe, while Braff's version is serious and lacks the lightheartedness that could have made it more enjoyable. The remake's attempt at adding depth through dramatic elements falls flat, and the result is a film that feels lifeless despite its talented cast.
If you're a fan of the original "Going in Style," I'd recommend sticking with that version. It's currently available on Prime Video and Apple TV, and it's a far more satisfying watch. Brest's film offers a unique take on the heist genre, and its sensitivity and character-driven approach make it a standout.
In conclusion, while the 2017 remake of "Going in Style" may have had commercial success, it failed to capture the magic of the original. It's a reminder that sometimes, trying to improve upon a classic can lead to a missed opportunity. Personally, I think it's worth seeking out the original and experiencing the unique charm and texture that Brest brought to this story.
