Welcome to 'Fanon Fixing Canon', a weekly column where we delve into the intricate world of canon and fanon, exploring how we can harmonize the inconsistencies between beloved shows. Today, we're focusing on the intriguing case of 'Young Sheldon' and its relationship with 'The Big Bang Theory'. The two series, while interconnected, have presented a myriad of contradictions, leaving fans with questions. Is 'Young Sheldon' deliberately ignoring certain aspects of 'The Big Bang Theory' to enhance its narrative? Or is there a more intriguing explanation? Let's embark on a journey to uncover the truth behind these discrepancies.
The Discrepancies Unveiled
The most prominent contrast between the two shows revolves around the character of George Cooper Sr. In 'The Big Bang Theory', he is portrayed as an alcoholic and a cheater, a far cry from the loving and supportive father depicted in 'Young Sheldon'. Similarly, Sheldon's Meemaw in the prequel is a kinder, more nurturing figure compared to her portrayal in the original series. These changes have sparked debates among fans, with some questioning the creative liberties taken by the showrunners.
One of the most intriguing aspects of 'Young Sheldon' is the portrayal of Sheldon himself. The series presents a more well-adjusted and socially adept version of Sheldon, in stark contrast to the eccentric and often bullied character we met in 'The Big Bang Theory'. This shift in character development has led some to speculate that Sheldon is crafting a more favorable version of his past in his memoir, a narrative device that could explain the discrepancies.
The Memoir Theory: A Possible Solution
The key to resolving these contradictions lies in the idea that 'Young Sheldon' is, in essence, Sheldon's memoir. This theory suggests that the show is a creative interpretation of Sheldon's life, written by the adult Sheldon himself. By presenting a more sanitized and favorable version of his childhood, Sheldon could be crafting a narrative that aligns with his aspirations and ego.
Sheldon, being a theoretical physicist, is likely aware of the impact his future achievements will have on younger generations. As a Nobel Prize winner, he understands the power of his legacy. It is entirely plausible that he would want to present himself in the best light possible, especially in a written form that will be accessible to aspiring young scientists.
This memoir theory also explains the stylistic choices made in 'Young Sheldon'. The single-camera format, the overly complex episode titles, and the adult Sheldon's narration all align with the idea of a memoir. The show's focus on Sheldon's perspective and the absence of a multicam setup, which is common in shows with multiple main characters, further supports this theory.
Embracing the Unreliable Narrator
Treating 'Young Sheldon' as Sheldon's memoir allows us to view 'The Big Bang Theory' through a different lens. Instead of seeing it as a conflicting canon, we can appreciate it as an unreliable narrator, adding depth to the narrative. This perspective shift enables fans to enjoy both shows without the frustration of contradictory storylines.
In conclusion, the 'memoir theory' provides a fascinating explanation for the discrepancies between 'The Big Bang Theory' and 'Young Sheldon'. It offers a unique insight into Sheldon's character and the creative process behind the show. By embracing this interpretation, fans can appreciate the intricate web of storytelling and the genius of the writers' approach.
